Some Remarks on the Assessment of Evidence

Abstract

The texts by Perfecto Andrés Ibáñez, Marina Gascón Abellán and Andrés Bouzat and Alejandro S. Cantaro converge to a large extent with the substantive theses that I have presented both in the article that is the subject of this discussion and, in a broader and more comprehensive way. in depth, in other writings of mine. Therefore, I am faced, more than objections or criticism, with a series of stimulating reflections that induce me to deepen, and perhaps also clarify, some aspects of my thinking. To do this it seems appropriate, in order to avoid repetitions, not to comment in detail on what each of the authors has written, but to focus attention on the most important problems they have highlighted.